Inflation Trends Affecting P&C: Underwriting Profits Still Elusive
Inflation is an economic phenomenon that affects almost every aspect of our lives, including insurance. The property and casualty (P&C) insurance industry is no exception. Inflation trends significantly impact P&C insurers, and understanding them is essential for insurers to maintain profitability.
When the cost of repairing or replacing a car or home is high, the premium rates used to determine how much a policy owner must pay should be proportionate. Yet, this has not been the case with homeowners or auto insurance. As a result, insurers find it difficult to be lucrative. In 2023, property and casualty insurers can find some solace in lower inflation and replacement costs. Nonetheless, most businesses will struggle to obtain underwriting in the foreseeable future.
Here’s a closer look at the inflation trends affecting P&C insurers.
Inflation for P&C Insurers
Inflation has different effects on different industries; the P&C insurance industry is no exception. Inflation affects P&C insurers in two ways:
- Cost Inflation: Cost inflation refers to the rise in the cost of goods and services that insurers must pay for, such as medical expenses, repairs, and materials. When the cost of goods and services increases, P&C insurers must pay more for claims, reducing their profitability.
- Asset Inflation: Asset inflation refers to the increase in the value of assets such as stocks, bonds, and real estate. P&C insurers invest in these assets to generate income and maintain reserves. When the value of these assets increases, it may lead to higher investment income and higher reserve levels for insurers.
What are Underwriting Profits?
Underwriting profits are earned from the difference between collected premiums and claims paid. P&C insurers aim to make underwriting profits, but this is easier said than done. Cost inflation, asset inflation, and insurance inflation all impact insurers’ profitability.
To make underwriting profits, insurers must price their premiums accurately. If premiums are too low, insurers may be unable to cover their claims, leading to losses. If premiums are too high, insurers may lose customers to competitors. Therefore, insurers must strike a balance between pricing their premiums accurately and remaining competitive.
Insurers must also manage their risks effectively to make underwriting profits. Risks can come from various sources, including catastrophic events, fraud, and underwriting errors. To manage these risks, insurers must invest in predictive modeling, fraud detection, and automation technologies.
Why Underwriting Profits Remain Elusive in 2023
P&C insurers aim to make underwriting profits, but these profits remain elusive due to inflation trends.
Here are some of the reasons why underwriting profits are hard to achieve:
- Competitive Market: The P&C insurance market is highly competitive, and insurers must compete for customers. When insurers compete for customers, they may lower their premiums to attract customers, leading to lower underwriting profits.
- Rising Claims Costs: Claims costs are rising due to cost inflation. Insurers must pay more for claims, reducing their profitability. Rising claims costs also lead to higher insurance premiums, making it harder for insurers to maintain customer loyalty.
- Low-Interest Rates: Low-interest rates make it challenging for P&C insurers to generate income from investments. Insurers earn less from their investments when interest rates are low, making it harder to maintain reserves.
- Catastrophic Events: Catastrophic events such as hurricanes, earthquakes, and wildfires can cause significant damage and lead to higher claims costs. These events are unpredictable and can occur anytime, making it hard for insurers to plan and maintain profitability.
During periods of high inflation, insurers’ operational expenses and claims increase, making it more difficult to generate profits.
Impact of Cost Inflation on P&C Insurers
Cost inflation is a significant concern for P&C insurers. As mentioned earlier, the rise in the cost of goods and services that insurers need to pay for, such as medical expenses, repairs, and materials, reduces profitability. Cost inflation affects various types of insurance, including property insurance, liability insurance, and auto insurance.
With property insurance, cost inflation affects the cost of repairs and rebuilding homes, which can be significant. For instance, the cost of building materials and labor can increase due to inflation, making it more expensive to rebuild or repair homes after natural disasters or other accidents.
In liability insurance, cost inflation affects the cost of claims arising from bodily injury or property damage. Medical expenses, for example, are one of the primary drivers of cost inflation in liability insurance. When people get injured, they may need medical treatment, which can be expensive, especially if the injury is severe.
Cost inflation affects auto insurers by increasing the cost of repairs and medical expenses resulting from accidents. When vehicles are damaged in accidents, insurers must pay for repairs or replacement, which can be costly, especially if the vehicle is new or high-end.
Impact of Asset Inflation on P&C Insurers
Asset inflation can have a positive impact on P&C insurers. When the value of assets such as stocks, bonds, and real estate increases, it may lead to higher investment income and higher reserve levels for insurers. Insurers invest in these assets to generate income and maintain reserves, which can be used to pay claims.
However, asset inflation can also have a negative impact on P&C insurers. For instance, when interest rates are low, insurers may not be able to earn enough from their investments to maintain reserves. Additionally, when asset prices are high, insurers may have to pay more to acquire them, reducing their investment income.
Request a Quote
At KSA Insurance, we work with employers in South Carolina and across the southeastern United States to help them choose affordable insurance policies that protect their property and more against a variety of common risks.
Contact us today to get a quote and learn more about P&C insurance.